Is the Widal test reliable?
The Widal test is the test most Nigerians are given when they have a fever. It is also the main reason typhoid is over-diagnosed in Nigeria. Here is what it actually measures, and what to ask for instead.
What the Widal test is
The Widal test looks for antibodies in your blood – the proteins your immune system makes in response to typhoid bacteria. It does not look for the bacteria themselves.
That distinction matters. Antibodies can be in your blood for reasons that have nothing to do with a fever you have today.
Why a positive result can be wrong
A Widal test can be positive when you do not have typhoid, because:
- you had typhoid in the past – antibodies can stay in the blood for months or years
- you have had a typhoid vaccine
- you live in an area where typhoid is common – many healthy people already have background antibody levels, so the cut-off used in Europe does not fit Nigeria
- you have another infection, such as malaria, which can cause a false positive
- only one sample was taken – the test was designed to compare two samples taken about a week apart, which is rarely done in practice
A Widal test can also be negative when you do have typhoid, particularly early in the illness or after antibiotics have been started.
Why this matters
Being told you have typhoid when you do not means:
- the real cause of your fever – often malaria, and sometimes something more serious – goes untreated
- you take antibiotics you do not need, with the side effects and cost that come with them
- bacteria in the community become more resistant, so antibiotics work less well when they are truly needed
- families spend money on repeat "typhoid treatment" for an illness they never had
What to ask for instead
- A blood culture. This grows the bacteria from your blood and is the most reliable test. Ask for it before antibiotics are started, because antibiotics can stop the bacteria growing in the laboratory.
- A malaria test – a rapid test or blood film – because malaria causes the same early symptoms.
- A clear explanation if the only positive result is a Widal test. It is reasonable to ask your health worker: "Was a blood culture done, and what did it show?"
Where a blood culture is not available, a health worker may still have to treat based on the clinical picture. That is a judgement about your whole illness, not about a Widal number on its own.
References and sources
- Ohanu ME, Iroezindu MO, Maduakor U, Onodugo OD, Gugnani HC. Typhoid fever among febrile Nigerian patients prevalence, diagnostic performance of the Widal test and antibiotic multi-drug resistance. Malawi Medical Journal. 31(3):184–192. 2019.
- Enabulele O, Awunor SN. Typhoid fever in a tertiary hospital in Nigeria another look at the Widal agglutination test as a preferred option for diagnosis. Nigerian Medical Journal. 57(3). 2016.
- Nigeria Health Watch. It's not typhoid – tackling misdiagnosis of typhoid fever in Nigeria. 2019.
- Akinyemi KO, Oyefolu AOB, Mutiu WB, et al. Typhoid fever tracking the trend in Nigeria. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene. 99(3 Suppl):41–47. 2018.
Reviewed by Dr Kene Igbokwe, MBBS, MRCS, MSc on . Next review due 30 December 2027.